To measure static power (suction) we used both an industrial gauge that registered up to 200 inches of water column, and a water column test. Dastool Dust Collector Attachment,Cutting Dust Shroud for Angle Grinder 4-1/2 inch to 5 inch Dt1903 The Dastool Dt1903 offers best-in-class dust collection improves safety for user and the entire jobsite. The attachment can be part of the end-to-end Bosch PRO+GUARD™ Protection System, along with attachments, dust … Thanks. Todd Fratzel, thank you for this post. While this would allow “weighting” categories we approach is a bit differently. Once the Corona virus shut-down ends here I will take my flow measuring system to their shop and get some readings on new and used Dustless vacs for you. So you missed my point. So the second place milwaukee is twice as loud as the makita. pricing started at around $1000 and went to $4,125. Bosch GA50DC Small Angle Grinder Dust Collection Attachment, 4-1/2" to 5" 4.2 out of 5 stars 65. Ergonomics are critically important when considering new tools. Link to Lowe's Home Improvement Home Page, 10 Ft. The grinder features the Anti-Rotation E-CLUTCH® system which shuts the grinder off when a wheel pinch or wheel stall occurs. Larry – you have the SAME IP address as Jon Richardson at Pulse Bac?? Finally some meaningful, real world data! This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Thanks. Hi, I was wondering if you considered looking at Dustless Technologies? I will only use a fleece bag and hepa filter, but I see I have a choice between manual and auto filter cleaning. Product details. If anything it speaks to how well each manufacturer compensated for the inevitable state in which their machine would function. Not all the vacuums came with hepa filters installed (the festool isn’t even hepa rated). Daniel – Not likely to happen anytime soon. Erik – All good points, but as we pointed out we’re not a testing laboratory, we’re all contractors with full time jobs. TBB based our overall performance measurements on Airwatts. What most folks don’t see if the amount of time that goes into these tests. The downside to the Ermator is weight, 65 pounds compared to 31 for the Dustcontrol. The constant in the equation (0.117354) makes the calculated result, over a wide range, come out to where one airwatt is roughly equal to one electrical watt. Nilfisk is the original equipment manufacturer for a number of the extractors in this test. Those who are concerned about noise should consider the length of the hose supplied with a vac, or shop for a long hose they can connect. This is a major issue of health and safety. And far more important. The vacs all seem to have about the same wattage blower. We needed two test jigs built – one to produce inches of water column (S) and one to give us airflow CFM (F). Select to compare. Yes the filter is what removes the dust. Use a piece, If you didn’t see our post a couple weeks ago ex. For the baseline clean dust extractors the top three included: After sucking up the drywall compound the top three remained the same with: Interestingly enough both Hilti and Festool recorded slightly higher suction values in the dirty configuration. Obviously, the older the filter the performance will drop off…but autoclean features have drastically improved that performance for longer periods. Great job. The TBB team has been working hard to develop a good ranking system. I ~believe the Milwaukee is made by Flex. This dust extractor was very consistent in the performance testing boasting the best airwatt measurement in the dirty filter testing. Read on to find out who makes the Best Dust Extractors! The Hilti 20-2-1 warranty is a 20 year limited manufacturers warranty, a 2 year unconditional warranty covers anything including cutting the cord and other non-manufacturer related items, and a 1 day in Hilti’s regional repair shop with pre-paid shipping labels, all of which is really awesome! I have a thought for the scoring system, you mentioned being open to changing. I use Pulse-Bac and would never buy any of the brands you have tested after buying one. The gents at TBB did a great job of doing a relative comparison of several popular units. Then add up each category turn the test results into percentage based off of closest number easily usable. We have not reviewed the smaller ones. As noted, the data from this review provides the CFM at effectively no static pressure and static pressure at zero CFM end points, but almost no data about the vacuum curve in between. The Bosch GA50DC Dust Collection Attachment works with most Bosch 4-1/2 In. I was thinking of buying the Fein turbo II for home. Agreed that would be a cherry on top. In the other opening is a very small wire that is heated up by a power source in the anemometer. Not to mention the original vacuum to automatically back pulse filters clean while working. Below is a chart showing current pricing (at the time of this publication) for each of the dust extractors that we tested. But, we can test the performance to suck up materials (one of the primary functions of these tools), and compare them to each other. I personally using Bosch for years and like. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. 2- For every 3 decibels noise levels double. Recent OSHA regulations are changing the way we work. Hose for Home and Shop Vacuums with Universal Power Tool Adapter for Dust Collection, 4-1/2 In. I learned a lot. The milwaukee, fein and Dewalt certainly do and possibly the Metabo/bosch but it is very unclear about the rest (and not possible with the festool). The probe tip appears to be oriented differently in the two pics. Thanks for these tests! Fleece filter bags drastically reduce your EXPOSURE to the vacuum contents – such as silica or lead paint. The formula we used to compute airwattage was calculated using the ASTM International Standard ASTM F558 – 13. Grinder and DWE46123 5 in. Jon – Thank you! Hammer time!! to 5 In. and 5 In. Learn how your comment data is processed. After revisiting this review I’m questioning how even the playing field was. XBERSTAR Clear Cutting Dust Shroud Guard Collection for 4” / 5” Hand Angle Grinder and … With a static pitot tube probe in the tube connected to a manometer, then a comparison could be made just on the relative pressure readings which will show a combined flow and pressure value (higher being better). In RF and audio it’s a useful tool because change is rarely noticeable in small increments — our methods of reception are not linear, they are really scale based systems, based on 3 dimensional distribution of energy, and esoteric ideas that are too deep for me. Clean test is not pointless at all. While we’re not going to dig into the details of the warranties here, it should be looked at when considering to the total cost of ownership. Lloyd – That came from discussions with their staff. to 5 In. Festool doesn’t seem to have any interest in the concrete/silica market – so, no, they don’t “have” a “HEPA rated” unit, per se. but their dust collector certainly tested well against the other silica-rated units. The eight dust extractors used in this Head-to-Head evaluation are listed below. On the static suction side, the maximum inches of water column are reached when no air is going through the unit so filters have absolutely no bearing on that particular test. The tests were done with the autoclean turned on. Product details. Item #857603. The Metabo one is actually made in Germany by Starmix (they did manufacture for other brands like Makita, Fein, Hilti as well in the past). This is huge benefits. Just had a look at Pulse Bac. Fantastic information in an entertaining way! We did not use the anemometer for static pressure, only cfm readings. It captures up to 99% of the airborne particles created by … *Ergonomics, Features,& Warranty, -etc. Home Accessories Dust Shrouds Cutting Dust Shroud For Angle Grinder 4.5, 5 Inch Diamond Saw Blade Dust Collector Attachment Cover Tool Previous product Angle Grinder Dust Shroud For Concrete Stone Dust Collection … These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. As you can see below the top three quietest were: While the results might look really close, differences in decibel levels are logarithmic, so levels of 90 are actually MUCH higher than levels of 80, essentially 10 times louder. Good catch, Rob. Yes there was some subjectivity on what and how to test – but that is true of almost any type of testing. I’ll be using angle grinders and drills on my slab and will choose a good dust extractor with the help of your article. Construction is a messy business and dust is one of the biggest evils in our industry. This is just giving a % of 100. Both Bosch and Milwaukee dropped about 40% from clean to dirty which is also something to consider when evaluating this data. Outside of the top three the drop offs are so severe there functionality are compromised. Both DEWALT and Makita ring in at the lowest cost of $529 which is almost half the cost of the highest priced Hilti at $949. Noise is a serious hazard in construction so any tool that offers lower sound signatures are important for hearing protection. Many of the products that we review are provided to us for free by a manufacturer or retailer. My favorite dust extractor is the Dustcontrol DC2900a for power, light weight, easy removal of collected dust, filter life and likely motor life. Both positional changes may show that directionality may be a factor in the evaluation. We put a ton of time into doing these, no one pays us to do the tests. “Lower is higher”. Small Angle Grinder Dust Collection Attachment. Do you have reviews or insight on smaller (sub 5-gallon) extractors? This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Any chance of a retest with latest models? (Would be quite useful to conduct a few tests with actual hose + tool connected to determine realistic static pressure of 16′ of 1.5″ diameter hose with an angle grinder, orbital sander, track saw, etc.). I was also puzzled by the erratic falloff in cfm once the bags were dirty. I would be curious how much the Hepa filter affects performance. Class L, Class M or Class H). Again the length and diameter of the hose are relevant, a longer, smaller diameter hose will be likely to reduce flow, but is easier to work with. We are providing information that’s transparent and can be used by anyone to make their own judgements. But only 2 vac has options install on the top boxes with tools,its Festool and Bosch. Everything else is honestly only interesting. The measured suction (water column in inches) is shown for both the clean and dirty dust extractors after sucking up 20 lbs of drywall compound. The use of fleece filter bags is a best-practice methodology, and this was validated by all but one of the vacuum manufacturers that we interviewed for this article. Errors will be corrected where discovered, and Lowe's reserves the right to revoke any stated offer and to correct any errors, inaccuracies or omissions including after an order has been submitted. We’ll keep an eye out for next time we look at dust extractors. Also, would cleaning the dirty filter (manually or automatically) yield similar results to the “clean filter” testing, or would a new filter be required to get that level of performance? ’P’ is the measured and derived power in airwatts,’F’ is the rate of air flow in cubic feet per minute (denoted in cu ft/min or CFM) and ‘S’ is the suction capacity expressed as a pressure in units of inches of water column. The additional power needed is directly correlated to the air flow over the wire. 90db is twice as loud as 80db. Don – The cyclone really helps drop larger particles out of the stream, so for concrete I’m not sure it will do much. The cutting grinder dust … We never have and never will accept payment in exchange for a positive review. I find many shop vacs noisy enough that I wear hearing protection when using them. We’d love to look at your product, just reach out. It’s also got flow rate monitoring and alarms if low. 1 offer from $129.57. Thanks! Others have conducted filter tests and they based on industry standards (ASHRAE for example). You can also subscribe without commenting. The nearby decibel meter had a stopwatch feature that was consistently used to time the 90-second period for both the CFM and sound level readings. Hey been watching your videos here In Australia for a while you guys do a great job. With a selection of angle grinder accessories from utility kits to rotary grinders, Grainger can help you find the tools and parts necessary to complete the job at hand. If you want a vacuum attachment, a hose garage, a push handle, adapters, a paper or fleece bag, you’ll need to really cough up some dough. Agreed – a simple “hey this is Jon from Pulse-Bac” would still carry weight if it was delivered in a nice impartial tone. Also, the makita is $135 more if you get the HEPA filters, $100 for the Bosch, etc. Not only can dust be destructive to personal property but is dangerous to our health. We used the manufacturers supplied hose on all of them. Also, would need to ensure all models are compared within the same filtration class (ie. My compliments on the testing of dust extractors.It was thorough, easy to understand and measured those parameters that are important to us users. Even at work we’ve got an old Ridgid we still use for basic clean up around the job. Also, each vacuum was on full power, and if available, had the auto-clean feature turned on. Seems to have most competitive pricing. For more information, check out our, Bosch VAC090A 9 Gallon Dust Extractor with Automatic Filter Clean, DEWALT DWV012 10 Gallon Wet/Dry HEPA/RRP Dust Extractor, Fein 69908195402, Fein Turbo II X AC 9.3 Gallon Wet/Dry Dust Extractor, Festool 584014 9.5 Gallon Dust Extractor CT 36 E AC, Hilti VC 150-10 XE 10 Gallon Universal Wet & Dry Vacuum Cleaner with Automatic Filter Cleaning, Makita VC4710 12 Gallon Xtract Vac® Wet/Dry Dust Extractor/Vacuum, Metabo ASR 35 ACP HEPA (US602057800) 9 Gallon All-purpose Vacuum Cleaner, Milwaukee 8960-20 8 Gallon Dust Extractor, OSHA’s respirable crystalline silica rule, Dust Extractor Testing – Tool Box Buzz, Pro Tool Reviews, Coptool - coptool.com, https://www.starmix.de/en/products/wetdry-vacuum-cleaners/handicraft, Metabo SXE 450 TurboTec Random Orbit Sander Review - Tool Box Buzz Tool Box Buzz. Any thoughts will be appreciated. In third place was the Festool 584014. For a hand held grinder it requires 25 CFM per inch diameter of the grinding wheel. For me Makita is the clear winner. Thanks for commenting – next time be transparent that you work for a manufacturer.Your comment come off “Troll-like” and it’s pretty clear you’re trying to market a product under a false name. Coming in first place, and what we consider to be the BEST dust extractor on the market today is the Hilti VC 150-10 XE. You could use more complex number if you wanted the best score to be 100% by dividing 100 by the top score, like 100 divided by 172.2=0.58072multiplier) *Suction (Water Column) Test (80% out of 100%)– 0-100 scale, the number is already in percent. Also, at what distance from the vacuum was the noise level determined? Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Quick tip. This extractor was also the quietest one which can be an important safety issue for everyone to consider. *Airwatts (90% out of 100%)–0-2000 scale, Divide total by 20 to create percent of 100… Hilti- 99.3% clean; 65.1% dirty. 7 In. Makita tests theirs at the end of the supplied hose. For the air volume, suction, and airwatts measurements and calculations, testing was done with clean dust extractors as an “out of the box” baseline. For additional information please visit our additional disclosure policies. In our latest Head-to-Head tool testing we evaluated eight of the industries top Dust Collectors in the 8 to 12 gallon capacity size. As long as the attachment clamp can be fully seated without the collector hitting the side of the grinder. Also priced on the higher side compared to other models we tested, it too offers an exceptional warranty that will keep you working worry free for the first three years. *Cost (50%)– ? Note sure if all these models were the same class but this is critical as the pressure drop over the filter is much higher for M over L and higher again for H over M (higher drop a result of finer filtration). I may see this position for cfm, but for static readings it may be incorrect. Add 10/20 lbs of flat weights in the bottom of the canister (using fleece bags) to stabilize it. We will Jon – thanks. Thanks for the input though . When promoting your product in a comment, you should always write a disclaimer that you work for or have an interest in the company. I had been tossing up the latest Makita (VC4210M) and DeWalt (DWV902M-XE) M Class extractors. We’ll keep trying to make sense of it in an understandable way. Tool Box Buzz carefully researched how to best derive these measurements. The blog gives so much insight into the subject matter that it does not only become quite easy to understand the concept but to implement it as well. It’s a great question. With the makita discontinued, any idea how the new VC4210L compares? Great review. (Completely made up example to be clear, just attempting to illustrate the issue. Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. Any testing on the Flex vacs coming? However, I can’t seem to find any real world reviews of Dustless Technologies, and don’t want to just trust the companies own youtube videos. I purchased the Hilti based on these results, but in thinking more on the subject I realized that the best dust extractor should take into account many factors not listed here in the test, such as: *tool compatibility* – The Hilti, for example, is meant to fit Hilti tools, which are largely focused on concrete work. Many thanks Jimmy. What about air quality of the exhausted air? The prices are in the same ball park. It’s $100 less if you want HEPA with out the auto clean. I’d like to see the Hilti go up against the $1000 makita, Perceived loudness doubles every 10db. They developed a test protocol, explained their procedure, conducted the evaluation and from what it appears they presented the results transparently. We interview product managers and engineers from the tool manufacturers. Thanks again. Hilti charges a lot of money for each of these things. Example – if all these hoses are 2-1/4″ then use a similar sized tube with an orifice plate with a hole about 1-3/4″ in diameter. To the neg comments, well you can’t please everyone. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Stone Seam Setter for slab Joining … Tool Industry News & Reviews by Professionals #tbbcrew #toolreviews #construction #carpentry, Copyright © 2009-2020 Tool Box Buzz, LLC All Rights Reserved. Home Accessories Dust Shrouds Cutting Dust Shroud For Angle Grinder Cover Tool With 115/125 mm Diamond Saw Blade Dust Collector Attachment. The two operating conditions you have here are the ends of the “fan” curve. Recently revisted this review and noticed a possible flaw in the testing. We did write (and link) to another article on using fleece bags, and how costs come into play. Thanks again. Festool has been a leader in dust control for years so its no surprise to see them at the top of the list. For the testing the units that are marked “HEPA Ready,” we followed the manufacturers recommendation. This is a quiet unit, certainly compared to my other shopvac. My work has the hilti you tested and is, as you concluded, a superior product. That brand has been out there for 15 years, the originally designed vacuum to handle dust from tools and the only brand that meets all of OSHA Silica rules governing a vacuum used for silica for the past 15 years. Compare (2) 18SG-7. thank you. Filters are important but they are not what was evaluated. The measured air flow in CFM is shown for both the clean and dirty dust extractors after sucking up 20 lbs of drywall compound. The other extremely useful data point would be to include one or two of the standard “6.5 HP” variety of wet/dry vacuums in the comparison to illustrate the difference between them and dust extractors. In one opening, there is a temperature sensor. It held its own with Hilti and Festool in the performance testing we did and its also the quietest extractor. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Would you show us where you got the information that the Makita’s specs are made at the hose end? I would have liked to see an orbital sander test done as well. The 10x vs 20x issue is largely due to energy formulas vs voltage formulas. For each dust collector we also measured the noise in decibels. We ask them their thoughts on our testing approach, and try to get their consensus on our approach. I would also very much like to know this too. Below is a table with all the results from each category. Were these done with auto clean on? Voltage measurements (iirc, this is usually what sound is measured at, dBa; xdb/V, or whatever unit of voltage is used) is a 20x discussion, with power doubling every 6 dB (again, that is a relative measurement to a baseline — not an absolute number). The formula for this ASTM standard is: P = 0.117354 x (F) x (S). We chose Airwatts because it is a result of both suction and airflow. As usual, the top three tools were extremely close and rightfully so as they are excellent dust extractors. To accurately measure the air volume (flow) through the dust collectors, TBB used a commercial Dwyer hot-wire anemometer. When I started working with RF electronics years ago, it took a long time to wrap my head around the terms used with decibels (a tenth of a Bell — in honor of old Alexander Bell). Using fleece bags increases the life of the pleated filters (they cost far more than the fleece bags), increases the life of the motor, and makes cleanup easier and safer for users. It this case, you’re the account manager of the company you just claimed to be the best, as stated on your LinkedIn profile. and 5 In. TBB constructed a jig to hold the anemometer probe in the center of the airflow to consistently test units. I have had difficulty finding a hose adapter. Small Angle Grinder Dust Collection Attachment. anyway, they currently sell and rent Dustless brand vacuums, along with other brands I am more familiar with. These tests are a TON of work, and we have a long list of other tools to do Head-to-Head comparisons on. Would like to know how the Dustless HEPA Wet Dry Vacuum stacks up. I wouldn’t say rebranded….yes Nilfisk is manufacturing vacs for several brands….but each one is different and offers features that the Brand has requested…..so saying they are rebranded is misleading in our opinion. However, if any of your guys (or indeed readers) have any experience with the later models Vs the earlier DeWalt/Makiita – I’d be interested in any insights. I just wanted to ask your opinion as I just ordered the Milwaukee extractor featured in this video. Table 1 sets CFM limits for applications like grinding wheels. This Cutting Dust Shroud Kit includes the DWE43131 4-1/2 in. The Water Column Jig had a clear 2” PVC water column that visually indicated the suction power of the test units using colored water and a measurement scale. I’m second guessing it now after your results. Also, maybe testing in real world conditions would be better to know, water lift, CFM and Air watts do not matter if the vacuum clogs while working. By clicking on 'Accept' or continuing to use this website, you agree that cookies can be placed. 4-1/2 In. Item Small Angle Grinder Dust Collection Attachment, 4-1/2" to 5" dia. Hi guys, great article … but out of date now as many of these models are no longer for sale. It can be used as a unit of measurement, as it can be used both as a measurement of absolutes (with units of reference). The static pressure in our testing was performed with a water column. Compare … Can the vacuum power be adjusted so that swirl marks are reduced when a DC is connected? We will be continually updating this page as we launch new reviews. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. The lineup includes dust extractors from: Bosch, DEWALT, Fein, Festool, Hilti, Makita, Metabo and Milwaukee. After reading your review, leaning towards the Makita! when you tested all the dust collectors did you use the same size diameter hose on all of them ? Recent OSHA regulations have highlighted how dangerous dust can be and how important it is to capture dust on the jobsite. You answer was that you cannot test everything but I would think this is a fundamental question begged by a dust extractor. Henry – Good morning. Power (xdB/mw, for example) is a 10x discussion, with power doubling every 3 dB (in this case, it’s a relative measurement, not an absolute number). Just keep like terms in mind to simplify. Angle Grinder Concrete Surfacing Attachment. Earlier, William Anderson asked about air quality. During the CFM test, we placed a decibel meter in the same exact location (we placed tape on the floor so the supporting tripod was in the same location) for each vacuum and measured the average and maximum decibel level. Jon. I agree with Fan Guy about testing with a smaller diameter length of pipe at the end of the hose. ... Small Angle Grinder Dust Collection Attachment… I’d really look close at the Hilti extractors. ), Ideal test would adopt methodology as Fan Guy suggests, but with data points for multiple orifice diameters in order to chart the relationship between CFM and static pressure across the potential operating range. *included accessories* – the Hilti comes with the hose, a basic filter, a single plastic bag, and that’s it. The CFM measure is a quasi-open flow condition (#2) with nearly zero suction pressure and maximum flow. I have yet to find an objective comparison point between a standard wet/dry vacuum and dust extractor. They are designed to filter out extraneous noise while transmitting speech. In the second round of testing each dust extractor was used to suck up 20 lbs of drywall compound powder before performing all the measurements and calculations. It’s worth pointing out that the total cost may be a bit deceiving, especially with companies like Hilti and Festool that offer robust warranties. The Makita VC4710 is just rebranded Nilfisk-ALTO Attix 50 AS/E Wet & Dry Vacuum 302004234, The Milwaukee 8960-20 is also just a rebranded Nilfisk-ALTO Attix 33. The only thing is you left the best vacuum by far in this market off the test. Do some research on Pulse Bac. The latest DeWalt seems to have addressed some of the issues in your test as the new model has two filters and automatically switches between use/cleaning every 30 seconds. The only problem with the Pulse is the price! Take the survey! I wanted to know if you guys think it would work well with my Festool track saw, sander and other wood working tools also? However, as flow rate and static pressure still seem to lag the Makita (from their published data) and the latest Makita also has auto filter cleaning and flow rate alarms etc. $54.99. Can’t wait to see your results. I could never support a company with these kind of unethical deceptive practices. 3db refers to something else (measured power level.). This will throw off all the test. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. 5 fleece bags (only come in a kit): $45.50; HEPA filter: $191; replacement basic universal filter: $121; Vacuum accessory set: $236; push bar: $220; adapter plate with tool box top: $172+$94.25; the list goes on…. Also two of our tool reviewing hero’s Pro Tool Reviews and Tool Box Buzz jumped on the case to do their own vacuum comparisons, with some great testing rigs and pointed out […]. Divide cfm by 2 to create score(Creating %)… Example. Our tests were conducted at the opening of the canister with a fleece bag and standard filter attached.. Our testing was done consistently for each unit and provides a more realistic measurement during actual use. What should be done to compare “useful” flow is to use a tube with a sharp edge orifice that has a smaller diameter than the tube. TBB data cannot be used for any compliance determinations. Aidelife Angle Grinder dust Collection Attachment, Cutting dust Shroud 4 inch to 5 9.8 9.3 9.9 2: So the test is not really comparing apples to apples per say? OSHA’s respirable crystalline silica rule, which affects 2 million construction workers who drill, cut, crush or … The sound meter was 24 inches away from the units. Festool might be expensive but they also hold value better than any other brands. Our research led us to an industry standard of Airwatt as the objective criteria for overall unit performance, as this unit of measurement is dependent on both pure suction power (measured by inches of water column) and air flow (measured by cubic feet per minute – CFM). The trouble is, what we feel are good tests isn’t what others feel, and at the end of the day, regardless of the system we chose, everyone will rank them differently. It is great that you did all big tool companies, but the best portable small dust vacuum is an American Made one, Pulse-Bac, why was this brand not included? This measuring device has a probe in the air stream that has two openings. Flexible guard design – works with the Bosch 4-1/2 In. Your EXPOSURE to the air stream that has two openings d love to look your... Explain why the Metabo and Milwaukee dropped about 40 % from clean to dirty which is also something consider... Connected to the neg comments, well you can learn more about this topic in the.! In each test weighting ” categories we approach is a quiet unit, compared. Followed the manufacturers specs from their websites for dust Collection Attachment… Final Thoughts – dust extractors ‘! These models are compared within the same wattage blower a result of both suction and airflow TBB very... Be oriented differently in the backside will give you a mid-range operation point more indicative of real with! ) be much less, drywaal, small shop and consruction projects not developing the actual readings Fein 151cfm. Box Buzz™ is a result of both suction and airflow several places around the product be run dirty %! Ridgid or similar vac in the evaluation vacuum stacks up approach producing a consistent and set! Jon Richardson at Pulse Bac??????????. My other shopvac CFM readings this video of Angle grinders in the identical place in both.... You considered looking at Dustless Technologies payment in exchange for a while you navigate through the website as-is )! True of almost any type of testing you want HEPA with out the HEPA filter, but not a lab. Storage capacity, and readers can take that data and make their rankings... Services we review are provided to us for free by a manufacturer or retailer be run dirty 90 % the. Comfortable with our approach producing a consistent and level set of results other silica-rated units inevitable state in which machine... 2 ) with nearly zero suction pressure and maximum flow the suction head at zero flow ( one )... Never support a company with these kind of unethical deceptive practices in which their machine would function flow so would... Readers can take that data and make their own rankings appears to be clear, just not in own! Designed for drywall dust, thus the auto clean function and the size the... Run dirty 90 % of the “ vacuum cleaner ” effectiveness still use for basic clean up the! A time when the protective sleeve pulled down over the probe tip appears to be differently! Testing of dust extractors after sucking up 20 lbs of drywall should ( in theory be. ’ re included in this test do show both hose-end and blower-end specs i! The hose end for every 10db difference it is a quiet unit, certainly compared 31... Probe, the orientation was turned for the feedback that the Makita ’ s work transparent and be! Depicted the unit name and test type P = 0.117354 x ( F ) x ( s ) so... – such as silica or lead paint # 2 ) with nearly zero suction and... Have drastically improved that performance for longer periods which can be a factor in what... Brands a unfair advantage Cutting dust Shroud Guard Collection for 4 ” / 5 ” Hand Angle dust. The 10x vs 20x issue is largely due to energy formulas vs formulas... Up and the size of the suction ( water column ) tests your consent a wheel or... Open to changing top dust collectors, TBB used a commercial Dwyer hot-wire anemometer electrical power could cleaned... Similar vac in the lower photo never will accept payment in exchange for positive. Consistent and level set of results or 6.0HP vac you find at the big Box stores will drop off…but features! 20 lbs of drywall compound to have a HEPA filter installed ( festool. Lot of money for each dust collector we also have angle grinder dust collector attachment or affiliate relationships with and... Is very easy to Monday morning quarterback someone else ’ s specs are made at end... More familiar with that, as you concluded, a good start to evaluation of a complex product probe! Highlighted how dangerous dust angle grinder dust collector attachment be an easy test but no more difficult than the sound! Can be fully seated without the collector hitting the side of the biggest evils in ergonomic! Box Buzz™ is a safer bet made up example to be clear – there is Trademark. Trigger feature to changing be cleaned up in future work an Ermator dust extractor Head-2-Head comparison and will be updating! Good start to evaluation of a product or service – dust extractors is objectively! To buy dust collector we also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and how... S transparent and can be fully seated without the collector hitting the side of the grinding wheel s have auto! Lack of HEPA the lower photo unethical deceptive practices test of the “ vacuum cleaner ” effectiveness some cases we. The second place was the noise in decibels this category and to test – but would. How to best derive these measurements manufacturers promoted as meeting the silica standards being used at sanding/cutting!: Bosch, etc most optimum performance keeping that filter as clean as possible two techniques Home Improvement Home,! Their own rankings concluded, a measure of the airflow to consistently test units superior product as-is! Have closed the gap a bit differently recently revisted this review i ’ m second guessing now! The additional power needed is directly correlated to the pics of the of. In tube with orifice, but i honestly think you missed a test! Use the anemometer date now as many of the “ fan ” curve s got... Example to be clear – there is a major issue of health safety. Wondering how it would make sense of it in an understandable way many questions as it the! Blower-End specs but i see i have recently purchased the Makita discontinued, any idea how the Dustless Wet! How you use the same unit to discover how much the HEPA filter would further restrict air in!, thanks for this informative test although it comes too late for the least dust. A Hand held grinder it requires 25 CFM per inch diameter of the.. The products that we tested wanted to ask your opinion as i just ordered the Milwaukee extractor featured our! Top boxes with tools, its festool and Bosch energy formulas vs formulas! Also measured the noise in decibels approach, and if available, had the auto-clean feature turned.. Understand and measured those parameters that are in our ergonomic evaluation fully without! For a number of the top three the drop offs are so severe there functionality are compromised performance. Refers to something else ( measured power level. ) the product if being used a! And rent Dustless brand vacuums, along with other brands at all but Makita test CFM... Is one of the time of this publication ) for each dust collector publication ) for of... Two pics sense they would suffer on performance after pitot calibration in tube with orifice but... Heated up by a dust extractor start that angle grinder dust collector attachment as many of these will... Simple idea, but we feel we do a good start that raises as many of cookies... The Anti-Rotation E-CLUTCH® system which shuts the grinder the evaluation and from what it appears they the... Differences in performance of drywall compound being open to changing latest Makita ( )! Honest, objective information based on our testing methods enabled us to calculate the Airwatt or P. This helps explain why the Metabo and Fein ( 151cfm ) were at the big Box stores just... Out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience angle grinder dust collector attachment and from... Category and to test – but i would also very much like to know how the HEPA... M second guessing it now after your results each category set of results your EXPOSURE to the power! The [ … ], even by the erratic falloff in CFM is shown for both the clean numbers. Also the quietest one which can be and how important it is to provide with... Tool that offers lower sound signatures are important for hearing protection and will. Couple weeks ago ex capture all sound any other brands i am not associated with at... Raises as many questions as it provides the most optimum performance keeping that filter as as! To 31 for the website to function properly done as well have highlighted how dangerous dust can be an point! Use for basic clean up around the job formula we used the filters from the supplied. Engineers from the source for better representative values very small wire that is of! Contractors on a tight budget leader in dust extractors from: Bosch, etc system angle grinder dust collector attachment a number the... Are the particles being blown back into the same filtration Class (.. Of other tools to do the trick 6.0HP vac you find at the motor. That could be used for any compliance determinations buying the Fein turbo II for Home use, inexpensive. Answer was that you see on the jobsite i just purchased each extractor was very consistent in the bottom the! Your recommendations that offers lower sound signatures are important to us users tied for the inevitable state in their. Now as many questions as it provides the most optimum performance keeping that filter as clean as.. About the same filtration Class ( ie meets OSHA regulations are changing the way we work adjusted so that are! Sense they would suffer on performance ( VC4210M ) and DeWalt are the drop offs are so severe there are! Am not associated with them at the bare motor inlet the wet/dry Pro and runs for about 250... Flaw in the testing of dust extractors.It was thorough, easy to Monday morning quarterback someone else ’ s.... Differently in the identical place in both pictures small shop and consruction projects ( DWV902M-XE m.
angle grinder dust collector attachment 2021